
Call Coaching: Why Shadowing Isn't Coaching
Listening in on calls is a lovely start, but it isn't coaching. Here's how to review calls together and pick one thing to improve.
I love when an owner tells me they've started sitting in on their team's sales calls. It means they care! But here's what usually happens next: the owner listens quietly, the salesperson does their thing, and afterward there's a quick nice job or you should have asked about timing. Everyone nods, and the next call looks exactly the same.
That's shadowing. It's a lovely start, but on its own it's watching, not coaching.
Here's how to turn listening in into real coaching that actually helps people get better, one call at a time.
Watching a call doesn't change the next one
When you shadow, you see what happened, but the feedback usually comes quickly and from memory. It's vague, and vague feedback is hard to act on. The salesperson walks away feeling either praised or criticized, without a clear idea of what to do differently.
Real coaching needs three things: something to replay, a simple way to review it and one clear takeaway.
You can't coach a call you can't replay
Whenever you can, record calls or video meetings - always with the customer's permission. For in-person visits, have the salesperson jot notes right after.
Replaying lets you both hear what actually happened, not what you remember happening. It also lets the salesperson hear themselves, which is often the most eye-opening part. Lots of people catch their own habits the moment they hear them back. Maybe they talk over the customer a little, or rush past a great question. You don't even have to point it out. Just press play, listen together and ask what they notice.
A simple scorecard keeps feedback fair and specific
Review the call against a few parts every good sales conversation has:
- The opening. Did they set a warm, clear tone?
- Discovery. Did they really understand the customer's problem?
- Fit. Did they find out whether this is a great match?
- Worries. How did they handle questions and concerns?
- Next step. Was there a clear, agreed next step?
Here's a fun twist: have the salesperson score the call on their own first, then compare it with your scores. The conversation about the differences is where most of the learning happens.
One thing beats ten things every single time
This is the rule that makes call coaching work. Every coaching session ends with one specific behavior to change before the next call. Not five. Not ten. One.
People can't change ten habits at once. But they can change one - deliberately and consistently. Next week, you pick the next one. Little by little, those single changes add up to a much stronger salesperson, without anyone feeling overwhelmed.
People can't change ten habits at once. But they can change one.
Kind coaching gets better results than tough coaching
How you coach matters as much as what you say:
- Play back a moment they nailed. Rewind to the best part of the call and listen to it first, so the session opens on something real.
- Pause at the tricky spot. Stop the recording right where things wobbled and let them talk through what they hear.
- Keep it about the call, not the person. It's a skill to practice, not a judgment of who they are.
- Hold the same weekly slot. Coaching that shows up on schedule feels like support, not an inspection.
A recorded call can make coaching feel like teamwork
Picture a small home-security installer in Spanish Fork. The owner used to ride along and give quick notes on the drive back. Now each person records one customer call a week (with permission), scores it, and sits down with the owner for twenty minutes to compare scores and pick one thing to work on. The salespeople say it feels more like teamwork than being graded, and the owner finally knows exactly what to help each person with.
Try this this week
- Ask each salesperson to record one customer call, with the customer's permission.
- Write a simple five-part scorecard for your sales conversations.
- Have them score the call first, then compare it with your scores.
- End the session with one specific thing to change before the next call.
