Clay still life for a sales compensation plan

Revenue Strategy & Forecasting · 3 min read

The Compensation Plan That Aligns Sales With Margin

Whatever you pay for, you'll get more of. Here's how to shape a sales pay plan that rewards the healthiest work for your business.

By , Founder of KGL, Salt Lake City

Here's a puzzle a lot of owners will recognize: sales are up, the team is busy, so why does the bank account feel so tight? More often than I'd expect, the answer is hiding in how the sales team gets paid.

A really common setup is simple - a base plus the same commission on every sale. It's easy to explain and easy to run. It also quietly rewards the wrong things.

Here's how to design a pay plan that rewards the kind of sales your business actually needs, without making anyone feel squeezed.

Your team is doing exactly what the pay plan asks

If a salesperson earns the same commission on a big, healthy job and on a heavily discounted one, guess which one is easier to close? The discounted one, every time. Nobody's being greedy. They're responding to the incentive you designed.

So when sales are up and profit is flat, it's worth asking a gentle question: what is our pay plan actually rewarding?

Nobody's being greedy. They're responding to the incentive you designed.

Four simple choices shape a fair pay plan

You don't need a complicated spreadsheet to get this right. Think through four choices:

How much is steady base, and how much is commission? The longer and more complex your sale, the more steady base makes sense, because people need to eat while a big job takes months to land. Quick, simple sales can lean more on commission.

What does a good month or season look like? Set a goal that's a stretch but reachable. Goals that feel impossible don't motivate anyone - they just make people tired.

What happens when someone beats the goal? A little extra reward for going above and beyond is a lovely way to celebrate your best months. People notice when great work is recognized.

What kind of sales do you want most? This is the big one, so let's give it its own section.

Paying more for healthy work changes behavior fast

If you can see which jobs are most profitable, pay more for those and less for the ones that barely break even. A landscaper might pay a little more on full design projects than on one-time cleanups. A bakery might pay more on catering orders than on rush jobs that need overtime.

If you can't see profit job by job yet, start with something simpler. Pay more for brand-new customers than for easy repeat orders, or skip commission on jobs that cancel before they're done. Then work toward seeing profit clearly. Your bookkeeper is a wonderful partner for this.

Before you change anything, talk it through with your team

Pay is personal, and changes can feel scary even when they're fair. A few things help:

  • Explain the why. Share that you want everyone rewarded for the work that keeps the business healthy, so it can keep paying them.
  • Show examples. Walk through a few real jobs and what someone would earn under the old plan and the new one.
  • Change it at a natural break, like the start of a season, not in the middle of someone's best month.
  • Keep it simple enough to explain in a minute. If people can't do the math in their heads, the plan won't change what they do.

A pay plan is a message about what matters

Picture a pest control company in West Valley paying the same commission on every service. The team sells lots of one-time sprays at a discount, while yearly plans - the steady work that keeps the trucks rolling - get less attention. So the owner reshapes the plan: a little more on yearly plans, a little less on discounted one-offs, and a small bonus for beating the season's goal. Nobody's pay gets cut, but the team's attention shifts almost overnight.

That's the magic. A pay plan isn't just math - it's a message about what matters, said in the language everyone listens to.

Try this this week

  • Write down what your current pay plan rewards, in one sentence.
  • List your three healthiest kinds of jobs and your three least healthy ones.
  • Sketch one small change that pays a little more for the healthy work.
  • Ask your bookkeeper how you could see profit job by job.

Salt Lake City

Ready when you are.

You make it. I'll teach you how to help the people who already love it find you.

Evan, founder, waving