Clay still life for a hiring scorecard

Sales Leadership & Team Building · 3 min read

The Hiring Matrix: Scorecards Beat Instinct Every Time

Hiring on feel can fool you. Here's a simple scorecard that helps small businesses pick the right salesperson more consistently.

By , Founder of KGL, Salt Lake City

I think hiring is one of the most nerve-wracking parts of running a small business. You've finally got enough work to bring someone on, you post the job, and then you're sitting across from a stranger trying to guess whether they'll be amazing.

Most of us hire on feel. Did we click? Were they friendly? Did they seem confident? That's natural. But the most charming person in the interview isn't always the person who'll follow up on every quote at 4 p.m. on a Friday.

Here's a simple scorecard I call the hiring matrix. It turns a nervous guess into a much better-informed decision.

Interviews reward people who are good at interviews

That's a real skill, but it's not the same as being good at the job.

Hiring on feel also makes it easy to hire people who are just like us, which isn't always what the team needs. And when you hire on gut alone, it's hard to learn from the result. If someone doesn't work out, you can't tell whether you missed a red flag or just had bad luck.

A wrong hire costs time, money, team morale and your own energy. A scorecard won't make you perfect, but it will make you a lot more consistent.

The abilities that matter depend on how you sell

This is the step most people skip, and it's the most important one. Before you look at a single resume, write down the three to five abilities that truly predict success in this role, at your business, with your customers.

When I was Head of Sales at Solar Works Energy (now Epex Home Performance), we grew the team from 3 to 10 reps, and that job was mostly door-knocking. The things that mattered were bouncing back after a no, handling questions calmly on a doorstep and warming up to strangers fast.

Someone selling event sponsorships needs something different - thinking strategically, building long relationships and working through contract details. Different jobs, different scorecards.

For a small Utah business, your list might look like:

  • Follows through without reminders
  • Explains things simply to customers
  • Stays warm under pressure
  • Stays organized with details and follow-ups
  • Genuinely curious about people

Past behavior is the best preview of future behavior

For each ability, write two or three questions about something the person has actually done - not what they'd hypothetically do.

Instead of asking whether they're good at follow-up, ask them to walk you through a time a customer went quiet and what they did next. Instead of asking whether they handle pressure well, ask about the busiest week they've ever had at work and how they kept track of everything.

Past behavior is the best preview of future behavior.

Hypotheticals mostly tell you who's good at hypotheticals.

Scoring everyone the same way is where good decisions happen

Give each ability a score from 1 to 5, and jot down what a 1, a 3 and a 5 look like, so you're not making it up on the spot.

If more than one person interviews, have everyone score on their own first, then compare. It's amazing how often two people walk out of the same interview with totally different impressions. Talking through those scores is where the best hiring decisions happen.

The scorecard keeps helping after the first day

In someone's first few weeks, check in on those same abilities. Are they following through? Explaining things clearly? If something isn't clicking, you'll notice early and can coach it, instead of realizing months later that the fit was never right. That's kinder for everyone, including the new hire.

Picture a family-owned HVAC company in St. George hiring its first dedicated salesperson. The owner writes four abilities on a card, asks each candidate the same questions and has his office manager score separately. The person they choose isn't the flashiest interview - but she scores highest on follow-through and explaining things simply, exactly what the job needs.

Try this this week

  • Write down the three to five abilities your next hire truly needs.
  • Turn each one into two questions about real past experiences.
  • Jot down what a 1, a 3 and a 5 look like for each ability.
  • Ask one other person to score candidates with you, separately.

Salt Lake City

Ready when you are.

You make it. I'll teach you how to help the people who already love it find you.

Evan, founder, waving