Clay still life for hiring a first sales manager

Sales Leadership & Team Building · 4 min read

When to Hire Your First Sales Manager

You can't sell and manage forever. Here's the time signal that says it's ready, who to look for and what to build first.

By , Founder of KGL, Salt Lake City

I have so much love for the owner who's still answering every sales question at 9 p.m. You started as the whole sales team - every call, every quote, every follow-up - and honestly, that was the right call. Nobody knows your work and your customers like you do.

But at some point you've hired a couple of people to help sell, and now you're selling and managing them. Your evenings fill with follow-ups, and the big-picture stuff you dreamed about keeps sliding to next month.

Here's how to tell when it's time for your first sales manager, who to look for and how to set them up to win.

Your calendar tells you it's time before your sales numbers do

A lot of owners wait for a certain sales number before they hire a manager. I get it - it feels responsible. But the clearer signal is how you spend your time.

Ask yourself: Is more than half of my week going to the day-to-day of selling? That's the calls, the follow-ups, checking on quotes and nudging your team. Or is most of it going to the thinking-ahead work only you can do - where the business is headed, who to partner with and what to offer next?

If the day-to-day is winning, you've become the bottleneck. Not because you're doing anything wrong, but because there's only one of you.

A few other gentle signs you'll probably recognize:

  • Your salespeople wait on you for answers before they can move forward.
  • Follow-ups slip whenever you're busy with something else.
  • You can't take a week off without sales slowing down.
  • You keep meaning to coach your team, and it keeps not happening.

Your first manager should be a coach, not a superstar seller

Here's where a lot of first manager hires go sideways. Owners look for the best closer they can find - the big personality who can sell anything.

But a great seller and a great manager are different jobs. A seller wins by closing their own deals. A manager wins by helping other people close theirs.

A seller wins by closing their own deals. A manager wins by helping other people close theirs.

The best first sales manager is usually someone who:

  • Has led a small team before, even a scrappy one.
  • Loves process and follow-through, and can explain the why behind them.
  • Gets genuine joy from other people's wins.
  • Is happy being second chair. You'll still be involved with some big customers and key decisions, because it's your business. They need to be okay with that - happily, not grudgingly.

Over 6 years of experience in sales leadership, I've found that last one matters more than almost anything. A manager who's fighting you for the wheel makes everyone tired.

A manager can't manage what hasn't been written down

This is the biggest mistake I see, and it's an easy one to make. An owner hires a manager and says, basically, please fix sales. If nothing's written down, the new manager spends months figuring out how things work - and may build something that doesn't fit your business at all.

Before you hire, get these on paper:

  • Your sales steps, from first hello to paid.
  • Your rules for moving forward at each step.
  • How you decide which leads are a great fit.
  • Your weekly rhythm for one-on-ones and pipeline check-ins.
  • What good looks like, like reply times and follow-up habits.

Then hire someone to run and improve that system. Without it, you're paying for a manager and getting a busy salesperson with a fancier title.

A slow, warm handoff helps everyone trust the change

Once you've found the right person, ease in. Have them sit in on your weekly check-ins for a few weeks, then let them lead while you listen, then step out and meet with them once a week about the team.

Tell your team clearly who to go to for what - two bosses giving different answers confuses people fast. And celebrate the new manager's first wins out loud.

Picture a growing roofing company in Lehi with four people selling and an owner answering every question late at night. He looks at his calendar for two weeks and sees most of his time going to day-to-day follow-ups. He spends a month writing down how they sell, then hires a manager who's coached a small team before and is totally fine with him staying close to the biggest jobs. His evenings are his again, and the team gets coached every week.

Try this this week

  • Track how you spend your selling time for one week: day-to-day versus big-picture.
  • Write down the five pieces of your sales system, even roughly.
  • List three qualities your first manager would need beyond being a great seller.
  • Decide which customers or decisions you'd still want to stay close to.

Salt Lake City

Ready when you are.

You make it. I'll teach you how to help the people who already love it find you.

Evan, founder, waving