
Your First Sales Hire: What to Look For
Your first sales hire can give your business a second engine. Here's what to look for, what to watch out for and how to set them up.
Your first sales hire might be one of the biggest decisions you'll make as an owner. It's the moment selling stops living only in your head and starts living in someone else's hands. Get it right and the business finds a second engine. Get it wrong and you lose months of time, money and confidence.
It's tempting to look for the wrong things: a smooth closer, someone from your exact industry or someone with a big-company name on their résumé. Those all sound safe, but they rarely predict success in a small, scrappy team.
Here's what I'd look for instead, the warning signs worth noticing and a simple way to set your new person up to win.
Your first hire needs to build, not just close
Hire number one walks into a business with no playbook, no scripts and probably no tidy list of leads. A great closer from a polished company can struggle here, because they're used to someone else handing them the pieces.
What you need is someone who can make the pieces. That means they're comfortable with not knowing everything on day one. They ask good questions, try things, notice what works and write it down. Over time, they turn your way of selling into something the next person can learn.
You can usually hear the difference in how candidates talk about their past jobs. Builders describe what they made: a first list of prospects, a set of questions, a simple tracking sheet. People who have mostly been handed a system describe what they hit. Both can be great salespeople, but only one fits a business that hasn't built its system yet. (For a fair way to compare candidates side by side, our hiring scorecard article walks through it.)
Coachability matters more than experience
Your first salesperson has to learn the way you sell before they can improve it. You know your customers better than anyone right now, and that knowledge needs to move from you to them.
So look for someone who is genuinely curious about your customers and humble enough to listen. A good sign is when a candidate asks how you won your best customers, or wants to sit in on a sales conversation before they change anything. A worrying sign is when they arrive with a fixed method and little interest in how you do it today.
Experience can be taught over time, but curiosity is very hard to teach.
Experience can be taught over time, but curiosity is very hard to teach. When two candidates are close, I'd lean toward the one who asks better questions.
Watch for a few gentle warning signs
None of these are deal breakers on their own, but they're worth noticing:
- They ask where the leads come from before they ask about the customer. That can mean they expect to be handed opportunities rather than create them.
- They've only sold with a famous brand behind them. Selling for a small business without name recognition is a very different job.
- They talk mostly about their own paycheck and little about the business. Pay matters, and it should. But your first hire also needs to care about building something.
- They're uneasy with loose edges. Early on, plans change often. Someone who needs everything settled may feel stressed rather than energized.
Be honest about what the job really is
The kindest thing you can do for your first salesperson is to describe the job truthfully. Early sales jobs are part selling, part building and part figuring things out together. Say that out loud in the very first conversation.
Be clear about a few things before anyone says yes:
- What they'll own, like new conversations, follow-ups or a certain kind of customer.
- What you'll keep for now, like your longest-standing customers or the biggest projects.
- What will still be messy, so the loose edges feel expected instead of alarming.
- How you'll decide together when something isn't working.
The right person will find that honesty exciting. The wrong person will hesitate, and that's useful too. A candidate who withdraws because the role is unfinished has saved you both a hard few months.
A quick picture of a good first hire
Imagine a landscaping company in Draper where the owner has done every estimate himself. He's tempted to hire someone from a big national firm. Instead, he picks a candidate who once built a sales process for a small gym from nothing. She asks dozens of questions about his customers, rides along on estimates for a few weeks and writes down every pattern she notices. Before long, she's running estimates on her own - and the owner is back to designing yards.
Try this this week
- Write three interview questions that ask for stories about building something from scratch.
- List the qualities your best customers would want in the person selling to them.
- Write two sentences on what your first salesperson will own and what you'll keep.
- Decide what effort and learning would look like after your new person's first month.
